日韩精品久久一区二区三区_亚洲色图p_亚洲综合在线最大成人_国产中出在线观看_日韩免费_亚洲综合在线一区

Global EditionASIA 中文雙語Fran?ais
HongKong Comment(1)

Henry Tang's challenge - defining just what WKCD is

By Peter Gordon | HK Edition | Updated: 2017-09-25 07:49
Share
Share - WeChat

Hong Kong often berates itself for having fallen behind the technology curve. But this is unfair. Hong Kong is a world-leader in virtual reality. Just look at the West Kowloon Cultural District (WKCD), and it has a new boss - or rather chairman of the board - in Henry Tang Ying-yen. Tang, who has been around the block, indeed several, more than once, certainly has experience to lead it, should he actually be given leeway - but the question is what "it" is.

The WKCD has been on the drawing board so long that Hong Kong has changed considerably since the project - and the justifying rationales - were first mooted. To take a simple example, Hong Kong now has a proper opera company - in fact, two. Opera Hong Kong's upcoming Aida next month has cast members who would not be out of place at New York's Metropolitan Opera. One can trace similar development in Hong Kong's classical music scene and the various arts festivals. The situation, therefore, is no longer a case of "build it and they will come", for "they" are already here.

The shortage of performing venues is a palpable and serious constraint on growth; just ask any local arts organization that tried to book one. While many events can and must be planned a year or more in advance - a not atypical lead time for securing a venue - not everything should or can be. It is true that Hong Kong has a number of good performing spaces - in particular at the universities - that are relatively under-utilized but the point of the WKCD is contained not so much in the "C" as in the "D"; to have a number of prime cultural facilities all in one place.

The efficacy and necessity of this can be debated. Some cities - notably New York with its Lincoln Center, comprising several performance halls on three sides of a large plaza - have such cultural complexes while others - including Paris and Rome - do not really have something equivalent. But the option of a plethora of theaters and museums spread around the city doesn't exist for Hong Kong, whereas the WKCD does. One needs to play cards with the hand one is dealt; and this isn't a bad hand as long as one doesn't discard the aces and keep the deuces.

As someone who has observed the WKCD project since its inception - what there was of it to observe - and who has been involved in various cultural endeavors from literary festivals to theater and opera, it has never been clear to me what the WKCD was supposed to achieve, other than broad generalizations about being a "regional center for promoting arts and culture".

The strategy regarding museums, for example, seems to have whipsawed from M+, a museum for "visual culture", to what might be described as a de facto branch of Beijing's Palace Museum. However grandiose these may be, neither would seem to target the broad middle of museum goers, those who throng New York's Met and MOMA, London's National Gallery and Paris's Louvre and Orsay for the paintings. Video installations, for example, are all very well, but are unlikely to end up as a poster on a student's wall.

The current debate, however, seems to concentrate not on coherent arts and culture objectives as much as on whether the district will be "commercialized". It is easy to come down on one side of this issue or the other, but as in most things, reality is nuanced. Culture that is completely divorced from commercial considerations risks being like the tree that falls in the forest with no one to hear it. At the very least, one needs facilities, exhibitions and performances that people actually attend; one should not turn up one's nose at Broadway-style musicals. Similarly, cafes and restaurants have - to the chagrin of many - sprouted in almost all the world's major museums. But there are worse things than subsidizing students looking at paintings by serving others overpriced food. But when the space becomes more about gift shops and cake than art, then that's a problem.

A cultural development like Lincoln Center, entirely set off from residential and commercial buildings, is something of a rarity. Theaters, opera houses and museums are often - albeit by circumstance rather than design - integrated into the surrounding urban fabric. While stand-alone temples to culture have their appeal, there is nothing inherently wrong with residential or commercial facilities clustering around - or these days, on top of - museums or theaters. If this helps pay for something that is unlikely to pay its own way otherwise, then so much the better. One can do this well, or one can do it badly.

And that really is the choice facing Tang and the WKCD. One often gets the feeling that culture in Hong Kong is considered akin to Samuel Johnson's dog walking on its hind legs: "It is not done well; but you are surprised to find it done at all." That approach would violate the point of the exercise. If the WKCD is worth doing, it's worth doing well.

(HK Edition 09/25/2017 page10)

Today's Top News

Editor's picks

Most Viewed

Top
BACK TO THE TOP
English
Copyright 1995 - . All rights reserved. The content (including but not limited to text, photo, multimedia information, etc) published in this site belongs to China Daily Information Co (CDIC). Without written authorization from CDIC, such content shall not be republished or used in any form. Note: Browsers with 1024*768 or higher resolution are suggested for this site.
License for publishing multimedia online 0108263

Registration Number: 130349
FOLLOW US
主站蜘蛛池模板: 激情啪啪网站 | 玖玖玖免费观看视频 | 成年做羞羞免费观看视频网站 | 成人一级视频 | 国产人妖一区 | 无码免费一区二区三区免费播放 | 国产精品揄拍100视频最近 | 国产欧美日韩视频 | 一级激情片 | 国内精品久久久久影院老司 | 国产亚洲欧美另类第一页 | 日韩和的一区二在线 | 天天视频在线播放观看视频 | 在线亚洲成人 | 国产精品视频播放 | 曰本一级毛片免费 | 视频二区 | 9277在线观看视频 | 超级成人97碰碰碰免费 | 中国妞xxx | 91在线视屏 | 久久久99国产精品免费 | 日本一区二区在线视频 | 亚洲精品福利一区二区三区 | 在线高清中文字幕 | 91免费在线看 | 成人久久久 | 久久久久99 | 成人午夜精品一区二区三区 | 激情成人综合网 | 99色综合| 97理论三级九七午夜在线观看 | 操日日| 色综合成人 | 国产高清美女一级毛片 | 成人v | 中文字幕乱码视频32 | 国产精品国产精品 | 欧美不卡| 色婷婷视频在线观看 | 免费视频大片在线观看 |